Demystifying Trusts and Their Tax Implications
Here’s something most people don’t think about everyday! Have you ever wondered about the ins and outs of trusts and how they can impact your taxes? Well, let's break it down in a friendly and straightforward way.
The US Tax Connection
First off, did you know that the United States is one of the few countries worldwide that taxes its citizens' global income? It's true! Only Eritrea, a country in East Africa, shares this distinction. Eritrea, however, levies a much lower tax rate (two percent) on its overseas citizens compared to the hefty 37 percent top rate for US income tax.
Now, here's where trusts come into play. Trusts don't have citizenship like humans, but if a trust is classified as a domestic trust for US income tax purposes, it's subjected to US income tax on its worldwide income. This applies even if the trust earns income from sources outside the US or if the trust's creator (the Settlor) and beneficiaries reside abroad. So, what determines whether a trust is domestic or foreign?
The US Tax Connection
To be considered a domestic trust, a trust must pass two tests. Fail one, and it becomes a foreign trust. Let's dive into these tests:
- 1. The Court Test: This one involves whether a US court can have primary control over the trust. Typically, it's satisfied when the trust agreement specifies that US state law governs its administration and doesn't include an "automatic migration" provision. This provision would cause the trust to relocate outside the US if a US court tried to assert jurisdiction. In most cases, trusts drafted within the US meet the Court Test.
- 2. The Control Test: Here's where things can get tricky. A trust passes the Control Test if US individuals have the authority to control all significant decisions of the trust. Even a single substantial decision under the control of a foreign person can cause the trust to fail this test.
Imagine David setting up a trust for his son Sherwin and appointing his non-US citizen friend, Frank, as the Trustee. This trust would fail the Control Test. However, if the trust had two other US citizen or resident Trustees and decisions required a majority vote, Frank could serve as a co-Trustee without triggering the Control Test failure. But if decisions needed unanimous agreement, the trust would fail.
Even if a trust has only US citizen or resident Trustees, it can still fail the Control Test if someone else not meeting those criteria controls a substantial decision of the trust.
Tax Implications of Trust Status
Now, what happens if a trust is labeled as foreign? The good news is that foreign trusts, like non-resident individuals, are only taxed on their US-source income. Income from outside the US isn’t subject to US income tax. Conversely, domestic trusts, similar to US citizens or residents, must pay tax on their global income.
But here’s the catch: US tax law makes it exceedingly tough for a US person to create a foreign trust benefiting other US individuals. If a US person funds a foreign trust for the benefit of another US person, they’re considered the trust’s owner while they’re alive. This means the trust isn’t treated as a separate tax-paying entity, and the US person must report all income and deductions regarding the trust on their personal tax returns.
After the US person’s death, the trust becomes a separate taxpayer. However, any distributions to US beneficiaries may incur a punitive tax and interest charge, known as the “throwback tax,” if the trust retained income from a prior year.
Asset Protection Considerations
Despite these complexities, some US individuals look into offshore trusts for asset protection. While discussing this topic is beyond the scope of this article, it’s worth noting that asset protection trusts are possible in certain US states like Connecticut, Delaware, South Dakota, Nevada, and Alaska.
In conclusion, while the idea of creating a foreign trust to avoid US income tax might sound appealing, it’s often too good to be true. In most cases, ensuring a trust meets the Court Test and Control Test, and thus qualifies as a domestic trust, is the way to go to navigate the intricate world of trust taxation.
We hope this helps give you some perspective and information and look forward to talking with you. If you’re interested in creating an estate plan to protect your family and loved ones, and keep them out of court and conflict, we would love to speak with you. Reclaim Your Legacy!
Book your free 15 minute discovery call here.
In Your Service,
PS - In my mind, the real purpose of a properly executed Estate Plan is to take care of the people you love, protect your family for the future, maximize the assets you pass on to the people you love and cherish, and keep your family out of Court and Out of Conflict. This is a very important and noble part of LIVING! Lavelle Law Group, APC would be honored to help educate you and assist you and your family with this important part of life.
Let’s talk –
Joseph Lavelle (Lavelle Law Group)
1350 Columbia Street, Suite 500
San Diego, CA 92101
(619) 515-1498
joe@lavellelawgroup.com
